Resorting to a Mesothelioma Verdict: Worth the Risk?

Mesothelioma trials often end in a favorable verdict for the plaintiff. Most national mesothelioma law firms work strictly on contingency for two main reasons: they are confident they’ll be successful in securing a settlement or a favorable verdict; and they don’t want their clients to pay unnecessary out-of-pocket costs to secure legal representation. However, because of the many variables of a trial, seeking a verdict can be risky.

According to the 2017-2018 Mealey’s Litigation Report: Asbestos, the median trial verdict for asbestos-related cases in 2017 was approximately $2 million. The average verdict was higher, around $9 million, due to two or three outlier verdicts that were much larger than most.

Reasons to Avoid a Trial Verdict

unpredictable icon

Trials Are Unpredictable

No one knows for sure what a judge or jury will decide in a mesothelioma trial. Reaching a settlement ensures compensation and avoids the risks of a losing verdict.

longer icon

They Take Longer

It can take years before a mesothelioma verdict is reached. Many trials last several years — and even longer if there’s an appeal.

public record icon

Verdicts Are Public Record

Every hearing and document filed with the court is available to the public. Settlements protect the privacy of all parties.

What to Expect When Going to Trial

The judicial process has been highlighted in movies and on television for as long as movies and TV have existed. Hollywood productions can overdramatize the intensity of courtroom events.

In situations where a successful negotiation prior to a trial isn’t possible, mesothelioma patients are dependent on a successful verdict to receive an award. It is important to remember, however, that attorneys will still try to mediate a settlement during the trial. Only after a verdict is reached is it too late to settle.

Trial Procedure

opening icon

Opening statements

evidence icon

Presentation of evidence

witness icon

Witness examinations

arguments icon

Closing arguments

jury icon

Jury deliberation

verdict icon


Presenting and Examining the Facts

Before a verdict is reached, both parties present evidence and cross-examine witnesses to bolster their respective arguments. A mesothelioma victim may testify as a witness if they are medically able to, but this exposes them to cross-examination by the defendant.

After each side provides closing statements, the judge gives instructions to the jury to rule on certain issues of the case and may point out certain facts and rules of law. The jury then deliberates until a verdict is reached.

Jury Verdicts: Types of Damages

If the jury votes in favor of the plaintiff, the jury sets the amount of compensatory and punitive damages. Both types of damages are payments made to the victim:

  • Compensatory damages are intended to pay back the victim for lost damages, such as medical bills or lost wages.
  • Punitive damages are intended to punish the defendant and set an example, hopefully to prevent future occurrences of wrongdoing.

The award amount varies given the compensatory claims of the plaintiff and the defendant’s level of negligence. The amount of punitive damages awarded by the jury depends on how much the jury believes the defendant was responsible for any of the plaintiff’s asbestos exposure.

If the jury votes in favor of the defendant, the company is not required to pay any damages. When working with most top mesothelioma lawyers, the plaintiff doesn’t have to pay any legal fees to their attorney if they lose their case.

Choosing a Good Law Firm

The importance of choosing a good law firm cannot be overstated. The ins and outs of mesothelioma lawsuits are intricate and a veteran lawyer can get the full compensation that victims deserve, whether they settle the case or seek out a verdict.

Seeking a settlement is generally safer than attempting to get a favorable verdict. The reason mesothelioma settlements are so prominent is due to the overwhelming evidence against asbestos companies.

In many situations, these companies have admitted fault and wish to settle as soon as possible to avoid greater expenses. In some cases where the plaintiff’s asbestos exposure history is staggering, or when an offered settlement is not satisfactory, seeking a verdict may be the best option.

Verdicts often award much more than the typical settlement. However, only an experienced law firm can properly assess the risk of seeking a mesothelioma verdict. If you have been diagnosed with the rare cancer, explore your options with our free legal support and connect with top mesothelioma law firms. They can examine the facts of your case for free and possibly provide an estimation into how much compensation your case is worth.

Last Edited: August 30, 2020.

Free Mesothelioma Guide Flyout Picture Learn More
FREE Mesothelioma Guide